That was the title of an article in The Glasgow Herald’s Sunday edition last week.
It seems that plans have been underway for this museum for 18 months. If that is the case, then why are they only publicising it now? As someone who was directly involved in a similar plan back in 1994, I have huge issues with so much of the concept.
What does Scottish Rock Music mean in terms of a museum? More to the point, how do you even define Scottish Rock? Has it been and gone and can now be looked on with archeological intrigue, or is it still developing; morphing into new styles and genres; constantly outgrowing the perceptions of what it once was?
…but wait! Is it a museum of Scottish Rock Music, meaning home grown talent alone? Or does it include interlopers from over the border who influenced our local bands or made their first historic tours in Scotland? Take The Beatles first tour (with that name, outside Merseyside) in the winter of 1963 – or their earlier tour as Johnny Gentle’s backing band, The Silver Beatles.
Even within home grown bands from the 1950s onwards, their family trees are incestuous, labyrinthine structures that require a level of serious archiving! It’s all in the past, I hear you say – but that is the problem. A museum is about the past and any music that is released onto the market tomorrow, is a work of (and from) the past.
Should it be that anything produced in Scotland, or by Scottish musicians anywhere in the world is automatically acquired? Or is it down to personal preference of a panel of curators?
My belief is that it has to be the former as we cannot tell what influence someone’s work today will have in the next years or decades.
It’s not just about having personal artefacts, instruments, stage backdrops and other related items. It has to include every mention of every Scottish band in music magazines around the world and every broadcast of any performance by them anywhere on this planet. Do we also archive every TikTok or social media post?
To me, that last point is the biggest problem. We’ve always had musos creating in their bedrooms and producing tapes and then social media posts – but now we have people creating non-existent artists and music using A.I. Maybe that needs a virtual museum!
Now, where have I heard that before?







